A Think Again Media Group publication
Sport Debunk

Will cutting all fat make you faster and leaner?

Dietary fat: essential nutrients, hormone measurements and endurance results

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Sport Debunk

Dietary fat: essential nutrients, hormone measurements and endurance results

Dietary fat serves several jobs that cannot be reduced to whether a runner becomes faster. It supplies energy and essential fatty acids, while the amount and type eaten interact with the rest of the diet. University of Illinois sports-nutrition guidance places fat within a balanced intake rather than recommending its elimination. Controlled studies also show why the opposite slogan, that more fat automatically improves endurance or hormones, is too broad. Nutrient requirements, blood measurements and race performance are different outcomes.

The National Institutes of Health Office of Dietary Supplements identifies alpha-linolenic acid, or ALA, as an essential omega-3 fatty acid: the body cannot manufacture it, so food must supply it. ALA can be converted to the longer-chain omega-3s EPA and DHA, but only in very small amounts. Fatty fish provide EPA and DHA directly, while flaxseed, chia seeds and walnuts provide ALA. These distinctions matter when comparing foods. The label omega-3 describes related substances with different sources and pathways, rather than a single ingredient present in equal amounts everywhere.

NIH also describes omega-3s as components of cell membranes, with DHA especially concentrated in the retina, brain and sperm cells. They provide energy and contribute to functions involving the heart, blood vessels, immune system and endocrine system. Deficiency can cause rough, scaly skin and dermatitis, although NIH says deficiency is very rare in the United States. Essentiality alone does not establish that a supplement or more dietary fat improves a finishing time.

Hormone measurements require comparable care. Lisa Moran and colleagues reported a 52-week randomized trial in PLOS ONE in 2016 involving 118 overweight or obese men aged 20–65. Both assigned diets supplied 25% of energy from fat. One provided more protein, while the other provided more carbohydrate. The protocol set a 12-week weight-loss phase followed by 40 weeks of weight maintenance; of the 118 men who began, 110 completed the first 12 weeks and 68 completed the full 52 weeks. Total testosterone, calculated free testosterone and sex hormone-binding globulin increased, without significant differences between the two diet groups. Those findings do not fit a claim that every diet described as low-fat necessarily lowers testosterone.

The trial was not an experiment on removing dietary fat, nor was it conducted in lean endurance athletes. Its two groups had the same fat target, and weight change was part of the intervention. Consequently, it could not isolate the effect of changing fat alone. Its value is more specific: the hormonal outcome depended on a documented dietary and weight-loss setting. Attaching a universal testosterone prediction to the term low-fat would erase the conditions actually tested.

A 2022 crossover experiment examined another measurable consequence of dietary fat in seven highly trained male runners. Each completed six weeks on a low-carbohydrate, high-fat diet and six weeks on a higher-carbohydrate, lower-fat diet, separated by a two-week washout. The assigned targets were 75–80% and 20% of energy from fat; recorded intakes averaged 69% and 28%. The higher-fat condition lowered triglycerides and very-low-density lipoprotein, while raising total cholesterol, LDL cholesterol and HDL cholesterol. Fasting glucose and glycated haemoglobin did not change significantly. Different blood markers therefore moved in different directions within the same participants.

That small study monitored blood lipids and glucose-related measures; those endpoints were not a race-performance result. It also compared diets differing in carbohydrate and protein as well as fat. Seven male runners cannot represent every athlete, and a change in one marker does not establish the overall value of a complete diet. The researchers themselves called for further work on the implications of the cholesterol responses. Their measurements supply evidence of physiological effects without turning a dietary preference into a universal prescription.

Louise Burke and colleagues tested performance directly in elite race walkers during three weeks of intensified training. Their 2017 study compared high-carbohydrate availability, periodized carbohydrate availability and a ketogenic diet supplying about 78% of energy from fat. Athletes were assigned to preferred diets, rather than randomized. The high-fat group increased fat oxidation substantially. Yet walking at speeds relevant to competition required more oxygen, reducing exercise economy. The carbohydrate-supported groups improved their 10-kilometre race performances; the high-fat group did not show that improvement. Greater use of fat as fuel was therefore not equivalent to better endurance performance under those tested conditions.

Professor Toni Gist's University of Illinois sports-nutrition course lists the idea that dietary fat should be eliminated for better performance among the misconceptions it addresses. Its framing is a balance of the three macronutrients, which differs from the zero-fat or very-high-fat interventions sometimes implied by sweeping claims. The primary experiments reinforce the need to specify the people, foods, energy intake and outcome involved. None of the studies treated a single macronutrient percentage as a guarantee of performance.

True or False?

Removing fat from an athlete's diet has no effect on endurance or hormone balance.

Show the answer

The Record

False. Professor Toni Gist's University of Illinois sports-nutrition course lists the idea that fats should be eliminated for better performance among the misconceptions it addresses, and states that low-fat diets can lead to hormonal imbalances and decreased endurance capacity.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Sport Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.