A Think Again Media Group publication
Sport Debunk

Eleanor Holm and the 1936 Olympic team

Eleanor Holm and the 1936 Olympic team

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Sport Debunk

Eleanor Holm and the 1936 Olympic team

Eleanor Holm won the 100-meter backstroke at the 1932 Los Angeles Olympics. Four years later she was not swimming in Berlin for the United States. Wikipedia says she was expelled from the 1936 Summer Olympics team by Avery Brundage under controversial circumstances. Olympedia says she was banned from the team, ostensibly for drinking champagne while in training. The two sources agree on the champagne and differ on the word used for the decision.

Eleanor Holm was born in Brooklyn, New York, on December 6, 1913, according to Olympedia. At 14 she finished fifth in the 100-meter backstroke at the 1928 Olympics. Olympedia says she won 29 AAU titles and set seven world backstroke records, and it calls her a highly talented swimmer. Her 1932 gold came in the same event she had entered four years earlier.

Holm competed under the name Eleanor Holm Jarrett after she married the crooner Art Jarrett in 1933. Wikipedia says she qualified for the 1936 Summer Olympics in Berlin, Germany. Olympedia describes her as the reigning champion who made the team for a third time as a married woman.

The trip to Berlin began on July 15, 1936. PBS says that on that day more than 300 members of the U.S. Olympic team boarded the SS Manhattan to travel to the Olympic Games. PBS describes the voyage through the racing shell carried aboard, the Husky Clipper, and does not mention Eleanor Holm.

Wikipedia gives the events on the ship in more detail. After a drinking party aboard the SS Manhattan, the team doctor found Holm in a state approaching a coma. Wikipedia attributes to David Wallechinsky, in The Complete Book of the Summer Olympics, a diagnosis of acute alcoholism. Various charges were made against her, and Wikipedia says Holm did not deny them.

Holm's own account, as Wikipedia quotes it, admits the drinking in part. She said she had a few glasses of Champagne. She also said a chaperone came to her and told her it was time to go to bed, and that she answered with a remark about the Olympic team. In her telling the chaperone complained to Brundage, and the officials told her the next morning that she was fired. Holm said she was heartbroken. She maintained that her dismissal arose from a personal grudge held by Brundage.

Brundage was then the president of the U.S. Olympic Committee. Wikipedia says he promptly expelled her from the team. A petition signed by more than half the U.S. Olympic team asked him to reconsider. According to Wikipedia, Brundage, who later became president of the International Olympic Committee, refused.

Holm did not compete in Berlin. Olympedia says she stayed on in Berlin and reported the Games for the International News Service. Wikipedia says she had been the top favorite for the 100-meter backstroke, and that she watched from the stands as the gold medal went to the Dutch swimmer Nida Senff.

Wikipedia also reports a later account of the grudge. Decades later, Holm told the Olympic sprinter Dave Sime that Brundage held the grudge over an incident in which he propositioned her and she turned him down. That explanation appears in Holm's later account and in none of the contemporary reporting these pages cite. The two accounts of the dismissal, the champagne and the grudge, remain side by side in the sources.

The sources also differ on the status of the decision. Wikipedia says expelled. Olympedia says banned, and adds that the official reason was drinking champagne while in training. The explanation for the decision is therefore stated in two forms: an official reason given in Olympedia, and Holm's own reading given in Wikipedia.

After Berlin, Eleanor Holm appeared in films and shows. Wikipedia says she appeared in only one Hollywood feature film, starring opposite the fellow Olympian Glenn Morris in the 1938 film Tarzan's Revenge. Olympedia gives the same film, calling it a Tarzan flick that starred the Olympic decathlete Glenn Morris. Wikipedia says she married the impresario Billy Rose on November 10, 1939, a year after Jarrett divorced her. Olympedia calls Rose the promoter of the aquacades in which she starred, and says that on her return home Eleanor Holm turned professional. Wikipedia says that at the 1939 New York World's Fair she did 39 shows a week at Rose's Aquacade.

Eleanor Holm died in Miami, Florida, on January 31, 2004, according to Olympedia, at the age of 90. The record she left has two parts that the sources keep separate: a 1932 Olympic gold medal that is not disputed, and a 1936 removal from the team that has been explained two different ways.

The Question

Why was Eleanor Holm, the 1932 Olympic backstroke champion, removed from the U.S. team before the 1936 Berlin Games?

Show the answer

The Answer

Officially, for drinking champagne on the voyage to Berlin. Holm admitted to a few glasses but said Avery Brundage held a personal grudge.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Sport Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.