A Think Again Media Group publication
Sport Debunk

Eddie Eagan and his two Olympic golds

Eddie Eagan: a boxing gold and a bobsled gold

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Sport Debunk

Eddie Eagan: a boxing gold and a bobsled gold

Eddie Eagan is the only person to have won a gold medal at a Winter Games in a winter sport and at a Summer Games in a summer sport, according to Olympedia. His two golds came in different seasons: light-heavyweight boxing at Antwerp in 1920, and four-man bobsleigh at Lake Placid in 1932. Wikipedia's lead makes the same claim, but its body says he is one of two competitors with golds in both seasons, the other being Gillis Grafström, whose only summer gold was in figure skating.

Eagan was born in Denver, Colorado, on 26 April. Wikipedia gives 1897 as his birth year, while Olympedia gives 1898. Wikipedia says he attended Longmont High School and spent one year at Denver University, where he won the western middleweight boxing title.

During the First World War, Wikipedia says, he was an artillery lieutenant and the middleweight champion of the American Expeditionary Forces. After the war he went to Yale University, won the AAU heavyweight title in 1919 and graduated in 1921. Wikipedia says he then attended Harvard Law School and the University of Oxford. Olympedia instead says he returned to Yale Law School and left it in 1922 to become a Rhodes Scholar at Oxford. In 1923 he won the Amateur Boxing Association heavyweight title. Olympedia says he obtained a B.A. from Oxford in 1928. Wikipedia says Eagan wrote in his autobiography that he modeled his behavior on Frank Merriwell, a fictional Yale athlete from widely read dime novels.

Eddie Eagan's summer gold came at the 1920 Antwerp Games. Olympedia says he beat Thomas Holstock of South Africa, then Harold Franks of Great Britain, and in the final Sverre Sørsdal of Norway. Wikipedia reports the light-heavyweight gold without naming the bouts.

At the 1924 Summer Olympics Eagan competed as a heavyweight. Olympedia says he chose not to defend his light-heavyweight title. It says Arthur Clifton won a decision after three rounds, and that the bout injured Clifton's hands so badly that he could not come forward for his next round. Wikipedia says Eagan lost in the first round to Clifton and failed to medal. The two pages describe the same defeat differently.

Eagan's Winter Games debut came at Lake Placid in 1932. Wikipedia says he was a member of the bobsled crew of Billy Fiske, who steered to victory. Olympedia's United States listing gives the four-man gold to Billy Fiske, Eddie Eagan, Clifford Gray and J. J. O'Brien, and the silver to Henry Homburger, Percy Bryant, Paul Stevens and Ed Horton. Olympedia's athlete profile says that at Lake Placid he "added a gold medal to the one he had won at the summer Games twelve years earlier."

Wikipedia says Eagan became the first of six Olympians to medal in both the Winter and Summer Games. It names the others as Jacob Tullin Thams of Norway, Christa Luding-Rothenburger of East Germany, Clara Hughes of Canada and Lauryn Williams of the United States. It adds that Eddy Alvarez joined Eagan and Williams in 2020 as the only Americans to win medals in both.

Wikipedia says Eddie Eagan married Margaret Colgate in 1927, a member of the family that founded Colgate-Palmolive. He was admitted to the New York bar in 1932, and Olympedia gives the same year for his admission to the U.S. Bar. Wikipedia says he then spent five years as an Assistant United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York.

During the Second World War he served in the Air Transport Command, and Wikipedia says he visited nearly every place where the Army had planes. Wikipedia says he retired as a lieutenant colonel. Olympedia calls him Colonel Eagan and says he received ribbons for combat in all three theatres of operations.

After the war, Wikipedia says, Eagan was appointed chairman of the New York State Athletic Commission. He resigned in 1951 to focus on his law practice. On 13 December 1948 he set a record for the fastest circumnavigation of the globe by scheduled airlines, covering 20,559 miles in 147 hours and 15 minutes with stops at 18 different stations, according to Wikipedia.

Wikipedia also records an appearance on the CBS program I've Got a Secret on 13 October 1954.

Eddie Eagan died in New York City on 14 June 1967. Wikipedia gives his age as 70, and Olympedia gives 69 years and 1 month. He was buried at Greenwood Union Cemetery in Rye, New York.

The sources disagree on his birth year, his age at death, the Harvard or Yale law study, the 1924 defeat, and whether he is the only athlete with gold in both seasons.

The Question

Eddie Eagan won gold at the 1920 Summer Olympics. What did he win gold in at the 1932 Winter Olympics?

Show the answer

The Answer

Four-man bobsleigh. Eagan was in Billy Fiske’s crew, and Olympedia lists him in the United States four-man gold crew at Lake Placid with Clifford Gray and J. J. O’Brien.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Sport Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.