Fred Lorz and the 1904 Olympic marathon: the car ride and the real winner
Fred Lorz broke the finish tape first at the 1904 Summer Olympics marathon in St. Louis and was greeted as the winner. He had not run the whole course. Wikipedia says he stopped running from exhaustion after nine miles, and his manager drove him in a car for the next eleven miles before the car broke down. Lorz then ran the rest of the way to the stadium. Olympedia says officials disqualified him once they learned he had taken a lift in a car for part of the course.
The race was run on August 30, 1904, over a 24.85-mile course, according to Smithsonian Magazine. Heat soared into the low 90s, and the roads were inches deep in dust. Smithsonian says the course had seven hills, and cars carrying coaches and physicians motored alongside the runners. One fair official called it "the most difficult a human being was ever asked to run over." Wikipedia says 32 runners started and 14 finished, the worst ratio of finishers to starters in the event.
Fred Lorz was a bricklayer who trained at night, Smithsonian says. He reached St. Louis through a qualifying race sponsored by the Amateur Athletic Union. Smithsonian calls it a five-mile race. Wikipedia says it was a seven-mile race at Celtic Park on August 13, 1904, and that the top eight finishers won a paid trip to the Olympic marathon.
Smithsonian says cramps struck Lorz at the nine-mile mark, and he decided to hitch a ride in one of the automobiles that followed the runners. It describes him waving at spectators and fellow runners as he passed. Wikipedia gives the same nine-mile stop and the same eleven-mile drive.
Smithsonian says that after the ride Fred Lorz recovered, and one of Thomas Hicks's handlers saw him and ordered him off the course. Lorz kept running and finished in 3 hours and 13 minutes. Wikipedia's results table gives the same time.
The crowd roared at first. Smithsonian says the cheers turned to boos as the truth came out. Fred Lorz smiled and claimed he had never meant to accept the honor, and that he had finished only for the sake of a joke. Wikipedia says that after spectators claimed he had not run the entire race, officials confronted him, and he admitted the deception while still claiming it was a practical joke.
The Amateur Athletic Union banned Fred Lorz for life. Wikipedia says the ban was commuted to six months on February 19, 1905, after he formally apologized and it was found that he had not intended to defraud. Olympedia says the ban was quickly commuted. Wikipedia says the AAU suspended him again in 1905 for running in an unsanctioned meet on Long Island. That suspension was lifted about September 1906, which let Fred Lorz finish fourth in the 1906 Chicago Marathon.
Fred Lorz went on to win the 1905 Boston Marathon. Smithsonian says he won it "without the aid of anything but his legs," after meeting Thomas Hicks at the 1904 Olympic marathon. Olympedia says he kept racing Boston through 1908, when he finished seventh.
Olympedia gives Fred Lorz's birth as June 5, 1884, in Manhattan, and his death as February 4, 1914, at age 29. Wikipedia says he died of pneumonia in 1914.
Thomas Hicks, an experienced runner from Massachusetts, led the 32 starters from the gun, Smithsonian says. Seven miles from the finish, his handlers fed him a mixture of strychnine and egg whites. Smithsonian calls it the first recorded instance of drug use in the modern Olympics, which had no rules about performance-enhancing drugs at the time.
Smithsonian says that when Hicks heard Lorz had been disqualified, he forced his legs into a trot. His trainers gave him another dose, this time with brandy. They carried him over the line, holding him aloft, and he was declared the winner. Wikipedia also calls Hicks the actual winner of the 1904 Olympic marathon.
Historian Clément Genty contends that Hicks also received a car escort and was physically carried by two officials over a substantial part of the final stretch, Wikipedia reports. Genty cites organizers who had announced that no assistance would be permitted. Wikipedia says the International Olympic Committee's Olympic Studies Centre replied that it could not revisit decisions made on the field of play. It also says the official classification had not been revised as of 2026.
The sources disagree on the rules. Smithsonian quotes a historian who wrote that the 1904 rules allowed runners to be coached and assisted by race officials. Wikipedia reports Genty's reading, that the organizers had banned assistance.
Olympedia lists Lorz's 1908 entry as did-not-start. Wikipedia says he traveled to London for the 1908 Games and did not take part.
The core of the story is common to the cited pages. Fred Lorz rode in a car for part of the race, and officials disqualified him. Wikipedia and Smithsonian name Hicks the winner. The pages differ on the length of Lorz's qualifying race, on whether Hicks's help was allowed, and on when his strychnine doses began: seven miles from the finish in Smithsonian, ten in Wikipedia.
- Smithsonian Magazine, How the 1904 Marathon Became One of the Weirdest Olympic Events of All Time — www.smithsonianmag.com
- Wikipedia, Frederick Lorz — en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, Athletics at the 1904 Summer Olympics, Men's marathon — en.wikipedia.org
- Olympedia, Fred Lorz — www.olympedia.org