A Think Again Media Group publication
Sport Debunk

When a team bats out of order, which player is called out?

Batting out of order: the skipped turn that becomes an out

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Sport Debunk

Batting out of order: the skipped turn that becomes an out

Batting out of order took a run away from San Francisco on 6 July 2013 while charging an out to someone who had not swung. Official scorer Chris Thoms recalled the sequence in SABR's June 2018 scoring newsletter. Buster Posey doubled home Gregor Blanco, but the Dodgers appealed because Pablo Sandoval belonged in that lineup position. Sandoval received the out, and Posey returned to bat.

Blanco had opened with a double and reached third on a sacrifice. Posey's apparent RBI double brought Dodgers manager Don Mattingly out to speak with the umpires. The correction returned Blanco to third, charged Sandoval with an unassisted catcher putout, and erased Posey's apparent turn. Posey subsequently flied out to right to end the inning. The catcher received scoring credit for the penalty against Sandoval, even though Sandoval had not put a ball into play during that turn.

Thoms recalled that the press-box documents and scoreboard placed Posey third, while the lineup card shown from the Dodgers' dugout revealed the discrepancy. The publicly displayed order differed from the official order governing play. Posey's presence at the plate could not, by itself, establish whose turn it was.

Little League's published Rule 6.07(b) situation sets out the same central distinction without the distractions of a major-league game. With one out and runners on first and third, an improper batter singles into center. A run scores and the other runner advances. The defensive manager appeals before the next pitch, requesting an out against the person who singled. The umpire instead retires the skipped batter and restores the runners to first and third. The appeal removes the results caused by the improper batter's completed turn.

That official ruling also preserves independent movement during the misplaced plate appearance. Advances on a wild pitch or passed ball remain legal. A correction therefore does not automatically return every runner to the position occupied when the improper batter first entered the box. The cause of an advance matters. In the published single-and-appeal situation, both advances resulted from the hit, so both are canceled. An advance caused independently of that result belongs to a different part of the rule.

Rule 6.03(b) of the 2024 Official Baseball Rules distinguishes correction during a turn from appeal afterward. Before the improper batter reaches base or is retired, the proper batter may replace that player and inherit the existing count. After completion, the defense must appeal before the next pitch or an intervening play or attempted play. A pitch delivered before an appeal legalizes the improper batter's completed turn, and the order proceeds from that player. Batting out of order consequently has a deadline as well as a skipped name.

The rulebook illustrates the timing with Abel, Baker and Charles. Baker bats in Abel's place and doubles. An immediate appeal retires Abel and makes Baker the next proper batter. If a pitch has already gone to Charles, Baker keeps second and Charles is proper. The same double produces different consequences because of the intervening pitch. This also explains how an improper hitter can return to bat after a timely appeal: the next place follows the skipped batter who has just been called out.

Little League's scorekeeping instructions assign the scorer a deliberately limited role. The scorer must not alert either team or the umpire that someone is batting out of turn, and cannot make a decision conflicting with the umpire or playing rules. By contrast, the scorer must notify the umpire if teams change sides before three outs. Keeping an official record does not supply authority to initiate every correction. The defense still has to recognize the lineup error and make its appeal within the applicable deadline.

The scorebook preserves the sequence through lineup rows and inning columns. Little League directs scorers to write down the batting order, use jersey numbers to distinguish players, and mark the next batter when a half-inning ends. That last notation preserves the continuation point after the teams change sides. These details connect the names on the card with the next turn, which a collection of hit totals alone would not identify. The notation tracks a turn even when an appeal has changed the apparent result of the preceding play.

The sequence can extend beyond the familiar nine places. Little League's tournament guidance introduced continuous batting orders in 2023, except for Senior League tournaments. The manager must include every player on the team and proceed through that order, with violations governed by the batting-out-of-order rules. Expanding participation therefore retains a defined sequence of turns. Batting out of order still concerns the person due next under the governing lineup, rather than automatically penalizing whichever player happened to swing.

True or False?

After a proper defensive appeal for batting out of order, the player who actually batted is always declared out instead of the proper batter.

Show the answer

The Record

False. The ruling makes a distinction between the proper batter and the person who actually batted. The person declared out is the proper batter, the one who was supposed to be up in the first place, and that out requires the defense to appeal properly. The penalty lands on the lineup slot that was skipped, not on the player who batted.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Sport Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.