A Think Again Media Group publication
Sport Debunk

Do you need intense gym workouts to burn calories?

How to burn calories without an intense workout

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Sport Debunk

How to burn calories without an intense workout

A hard hour in the gym feels like the only way to burn calories, and it is easy to assume lighter movement does not count. The American College of Sports Medicine takes that belief on directly in its weight-loss series. Its entry on whether burning calories requires high-intensity workouts and long sessions opens with a flat statement: "All physical activity burns calories."

The college does not claim every minute burns the same amount. "More intensity equals greater caloric burn," its entry says. Moderate-to-vigorous exercise is recommended, and the goal, in the college's words, is to work toward "burning as many calories as possible through accumulating physical activity minutes." The key word is accumulating. Calories burned add up across the day, so a short, easy session contributes to the total just as a long, hard one does, only by a different amount.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention explain how intensity is sorted into categories. Aerobic intensity is "how hard a person works to do an activity," and it can be measured on a relative scale from 0 to 10, where 0 is the effort of sitting and 10 is maximal effort. Moderate intensity is about a 5 or 6, and vigorous intensity starts at about a 7 or 8. The same activity can be vigorous for one person and moderate for a fitter person, so the label belongs to the effort, not the activity itself.

A talk test gives a rule of thumb. At moderate intensity, a person can talk but not sing. At vigorous intensity, a person cannot say more than a few words without pausing for breath. The CDC also offers an absolute measure, the MET, or metabolic equivalent of task, which estimates the oxygen the body uses. One MET equals the energy or oxygen used while sitting quietly. Moderate intensity runs from 3 to 5.9 METs and vigorous intensity is 6.0 METs or more.

The CDC's examples show how wide the moderate category is. Brisk walking at 2.5 miles per hour or faster, recreational swimming, bicycling under 10 miles per hour on level ground, doubles tennis, active yoga such as vinyasa, ballroom or line dancing, general yard and home repair work, and water aerobics all count as moderate. Vigorous examples include jogging or running, lap swimming, singles tennis, vigorous dancing, bicycling over 10 miles per hour, jumping rope, heavy yard work such as digging or shoveling, and vigorous step aerobics or kickboxing.

Totals are what the national guidelines count, and a person can burn calories in any mix of intensities. The CDC's guidance for adults is 150 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic activity per week, such as 30 minutes a day, five days a week, or 75 minutes of vigorous-intensity activity per week, described as 1 hour and 15 minutes. An equivalent combination of the two also counts. The page sets no minimum bout length, so activity can be spread across the week and split into shorter periods. It also says going beyond those amounts yields even more health benefits, and that adults who sit less and do any amount of moderate or vigorous activity still gain some benefits. In the CDC's words, "Some physical activity is better than none."

Lighter activity has measured results. The American College of Sports Medicine cites a study of 260 adults in a weight-management program. After 18 months, participants who did more light-intensity activity beyond their structured moderate-to-vigorous exercise lost more weight. The college's advice is to focus on "moving more and sitting less" throughout the day. It points to the Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans, which count every minute, and it describes even a one-minute activity break as a step in a positive direction. A 10-minute walk at lunch is its example of a starter habit.

Choosing the activity is a personal matter. The college notes that no one exercise mode is perfect, so the best choice depends on the individual's preferences, injuries, schedule and body weight. A plan that people enjoy and can keep up is worth more than a plan that demands intensity they cannot sustain. The practical point is that the gym is one place to burn calories, not the only one.

The college adds a caution about measuring the burn. In a related entry in the same series, it reports that activity trackers have been found to be 27 to 93 percent inaccurate depending on brand, and that people estimating exercise without trackers overreport it by up to 51 percent. Adults trying to lose weight underreport their food intake by up to 47 percent. For that reason, the college suggests treating exercise as a buffer against recording errors rather than as permission to eat more.

Exercise also does more than burn calories. The college says studies show a slowing of muscle mass loss whenever physical activity is part of a weight loss plan, and that high levels of activity, upwards of 225 to 250 minutes per week, seem to be important for keeping weight off after it is lost. Both kinds of numbers lead to the same conclusion. People burn calories is a matter of accumulated movement at whatever intensity a person can sustain, with harder effort burning more per minute and more minutes burning more in total.

True or False?

Only high-intensity exercise burns a meaningful number of calories.

Show the answer

The Record

The American College of Sports Medicine gives a broader picture: all physical activity burns calories. More intensity does equal a greater caloric burn — but so does more overall volume, even at lower intensities and shorter durations. That walk to the mailbox counts. The treadmill doesn't hold a monopoly on the burn. Source: American College of Sports Medicine, Mythbusting | Weight Loss (acsm.org).

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Sport Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.