Abner Doubleday and the records of baseball’s beginnings
Abner Doubleday received credit for inventing baseball in 1839 from a commission reporting in 1907. An older municipal record places a game called baseball in Massachusetts decades before that supposed beginning. Meanwhile, surviving club papers show baseball rules being proposed, revised and submitted for collective adoption in the 1850s. Those records concern different things: a named game already being played, the regulation of club competition, and a much later decision to attach the sport's creation to one man.
The earlier record is a 1791 Pittsfield bylaw. John Thorn reproduces its language in a discussion published by the Society for American Baseball Research. To protect a newly built meeting house, particularly its windows, the town prohibited several ball games within 80 yards of the building. Baseball appears alongside wicket, cricket, batball, football, cats and fives. This is a restriction on an existing activity, embedded among other games recognized by the town. Its subject is where people could play, rather than who first devised the game.
Thorn also distinguishes that municipal evidence from a claim that Pittsfield invented baseball. His later interpretation rejects that leap. The ordinance identifies a game by name in a particular place; it is not a founding declaration or a full description of modern rules. The important date is nevertheless 1791. Baseball was sufficiently recognizable to be named in a town regulation well before the 1839 event later assigned to Abner Doubleday.
The testimony behind the later attribution arrived in two letters written by Abner Graves in 1905. Mark Pestana's SABR research identifies their dates as April 3 and November 17. Graves recalled childhood play in Cooperstown and credited Abner Doubleday with introducing a form of baseball. But his dating was uncertain. Pestana reproduces the alternatives from the November letter: 1839, 1840 or 1841. A commission's eventual choice of 1839 therefore narrowed a range supplied by a witness writing more than 60 years after the supposed event.
There is a separate problem with identifying the future Civil War general as the inventor. Pestana places his departure for West Point by September 1838. That timeline conflicts with the familiar image of Abner Doubleday organizing the Cooperstown game in 1839. The letters remain evidence of what Graves later remembered and asserted. They are different in character from a town regulation written while the prohibited games were being played or club documents prepared during debates over rules.
The National Baseball Hall of Fame's history of Doubleday Field reproduces the commission's conclusion from December 30, 1907. It credits the first scheme for baseball to Abner Doubleday at Cooperstown in 1839, qualifying the finding as based on the best evidence then obtainable. The dated conclusion establishes that the commission made this attribution. Subsequent local action gave it a physical setting: in 1919, a Cooperstown committee leased the Phinney property for two years with an option to buy for $5,000.
The same museum history reproduces correspondence from the resulting fundraising campaign. In August 1920, New York Governor Alfred E. Smith's office offered a dollar, provided his name would not be used to publicize the contribution. In 1923, village taxpayers authorized purchase of the field, and a September 29 court order transferred its title to Cooperstown. Those records document the making of a memorial. The lease, contribution and property transfer describe how people preserved the claimed birthplace; they do not supply contemporary testimony from an 1839 game.
For the development of playing rules, the Hall's Rules of Base Ball exhibition displays a different kind of evidence. Its catalogue identifies three surviving handwritten drafts prepared around the 1857 convention of baseball clubs, loaned by Hayden Trubitt. Before the convention, local clubs had differing regulations, including differences in pitching and even the size of the ball. Agreeing on conditions before individual matches caused delays. The Knickerbocker club called for a convention to establish rules that clubs could share.
The museum distinguishes an early draft, an incomplete later draft and the final draft further edited at the convention. Its description traces a committee reviewing proposals line by line before presenting them to delegates. The fourth page of the early Rules for Match Games of Base Ball makes this collective process concrete. Captains could change fielding positions, and an injured player could be replaced by another club member. Umpires and the referee were disqualified if they held a financial interest in a bet on the match.
The same page asks the convention to discourage gambling on the field and gambling-related remarks within the players' hearing. Its closing proposal sends the convention's decisions back to each club for ratification. Clubs were to publish acceptance or rejection in the Mercury and Porter's Spirit of the Times. The proposed system links rule changes to club approval and public notice. These surviving papers place responsibility across participating clubs, quite apart from the commission's later attribution of the whole game to Abner Doubleday.
- SABR, John Thorn (2011): The Pittsfield “Baseball” Bylaw of 1791 — reproduced ordinance language — sabr.org
- SABR, Mark Pestana (2014): Circa 1840, The legendary Doubleday Game — Graves letter dates and quoted recollections — sabr.org
- National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, History of Doubleday Field — 1907 report and later correspondence — baseballhall.org
- National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, The Rules of Base Ball — catalogue of three surviving 1857 drafts — baseballhall.org
- Knickerbocker Base Ball Club, Rules for Match Games of Base Ball, page 4 — museum scan and transcription — baseballhall.org
- SABR, Monica Nucciarone: Alexander Cartwright — evidence for his role in early baseball — sabr.org