A Think Again Media Group publication
Sport Debunk

Does a hard hit always mean a concussion?

Whether a concussion happened: why the size of a hit cannot say

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Sport Debunk

Whether a concussion happened: why the size of a hit cannot say

Sports medicine has never found a force that marks the line between a hit that causes a concussion and one that does not. Matt Gammons, writing for the American Medical Society for Sports Medicine in 2014, put it plainly: "we still have not found a level of force that definitely causes a concussion." Forces do not reliably predict injury, he wrote, which is why an athlete who reports symptoms after any head contact deserves to be heard. At times high forces do not cause an injury and relatively lower ones may.

The definition itself explains why force alone is not the test. The sixth international consensus statement on concussion in sport, published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine in 2023, defines sport-related concussion as a traumatic brain injury caused by a direct blow to the head, neck or body that sends an impulsive force to the brain. That force starts a neurotransmitter and metabolic cascade, with possible axonal injury, blood flow change and inflammation. Gammons adds that concussions can occur without any head contact, since rotational forces such as a tumbling fall can cause them. The panel accepted its definition by a 78.6 percent majority, short of its 80 percent consensus line.

The measurements show how wide the gap between force and injury can be. A clinical review of head impact measurement devices by Williams, Dowling and O'Connor in Sports Health states that "no linear and/or rotational concussive threshold has been established." It adds that many impacts at similar magnitudes do not result in a concussive injury, and it names sex, age, genotype and concussion history as covariates. Across college studies, the average linear acceleration at a concussion ranged from 55.8 g to 168.8 g, with no consistency from one study to the next. The rotational averages ran from 163.4 to 15,397.1 radians per second squared. In high school athletes, reported linear accelerations at concussion spanned 74 g to 146 g, with a mean of 105 g.

Those numbers also explain why gadgets have not solved the problem. The review identified 24 head impact devices, seven from peer-reviewed studies and 17 from a Google search of commercial products, and only 10 of the 24 had publications supporting their use. The most widely used, the Head Impact Telemetry System, relies on six single-axis accelerometers sampling at 1,000 hertz. A single accelerometer on the head or helmet gives limited information, the authors write, because headbands can slip and helmet motion is largely independent of head motion. In sports without helmets, skin movement and sweat can add error. Their conclusion is that impact monitors cannot replace a clinician's judgment and should not be used as a single assessment tool for concussion.

Gammons reaches the same place from the sideline. In-helmet "concussion alarms" are not recommended, he writes, because no known force level causes concussion, so such devices would likely cause both over-diagnosis and under-diagnosis.

What clinicians use instead is history and examination. According to Gammons, the diagnosis of a concussion is mainly based on the history and physical examination, and no single test can determine whether one has occurred. Symptoms include headache, dizziness, nausea or vomiting, amnesia, brief loss of consciousness and trouble concentrating, and they may last days to weeks. The consensus definition says the clinical picture may or may not involve loss of consciousness. Imaging does not settle the matter. Gammons writes that CT scans and MRI rarely indicate concussions and are used mainly when an examination suggests structural injury, such as bleeding or swelling. The consensus definition likewise says that no abnormality is seen on standard structural neuroimaging, although research imaging may show changes in function, blood flow or metabolism.

Timing complicates any judgment made at the moment of impact. The consensus definition says symptoms and signs may present immediately or evolve over minutes or hours, its assessment section says they may evolve over minutes, hours or days, and it describes serial re-evaluation of a suspected concussion over the coming hours and days. Earlier versions of the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool discriminated best between concussed and non-concussed athletes within 72 hours of injury and up to five to seven days, though their usefulness diminished after 72 hours.

Gammons notes a related shift away from labels based on how bad a hit looked. The newer guidance is not to grade concussions, because early symptoms do not reliably predict severity or recovery time. The consensus definition adds that most symptoms and signs commonly resolve within days but may be prolonged. Possible risk factors, including genetics, gender, playing position, migraines, prior concussions and mental health disorders, have unclear individual contributions. Gammons also reports that there is no evidence athletes develop a lower force threshold after each concussion, and that some small studies found the opposite.

Exposure does track with injury, even where force does not. The consensus statement credits a policy disallowing body checking in child or adolescent ice hockey with reducing the concussion rate in games by 58 percent, and says policies limiting contact practice in American football across all age groups have been followed by an overall 64 percent reduction in practice-related concussions. Gammons reports about two million sport-related concussions each year in the United States, likely an undercount, and names continued exposure as probably the largest risk factor for recurrence.

True or False?

Only a hard hit to the head can cause a concussion.

Show the answer

The Record

False. No level of force has been found that definitely causes a concussion. At times high forces do not cause an injury and relatively lower ones may.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Sport Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.