A Think Again Media Group publication
Sport Debunk

The day a golf course lost four holes

How St Andrews settled golf on 18 holes

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Sport Debunk

How St Andrews settled golf on 18 holes

A round of golf has not always meant 18 holes. On October 4, 1764, the Society of St Andrews Golfers decided to reduce the round on its links from 22 holes to 18. The familiar number grew out of a change to one Scottish course, and other clubs adopted it over time. It was a stage in the game's development, rather than a format inherited from its earliest days.

Golf at St Andrews has a much longer history than that decision. Archbishop John Hamilton's charter of 1552 preserved the townspeople's right to play on the links. Guinness World Records cites this document in recognizing the Old Course as the world's oldest golf course. The charter dealt principally with Hamilton's permission to breed rabbits, while also allowing the townspeople to continue golf and other pastimes. Its language records an existing activity, rather than describing the construction of a new course with a specified number of holes.

The golfing society arrived later. In 1754, 22 noblemen, professors and landowners founded the Society of St Andrews Golfers. In 1834, King William IV granted royal recognition, and the organization became known as the Royal and Ancient Golf Club of St Andrews. The royal title came 80 years after the society's foundation and 70 years after the decision to shorten the round. None makes the course's 1764 alteration a rule dating from the beginning of golf.

The old layout ran out and back over shared ground. Before the change, players completed 22 holes, using most of the same holes in both directions. The first four holes were combined into two on the outward journey, with the corresponding reduction on the return journey. That removed two holes from each half of the round, four in total, leaving 18 holes. The first four and last four therefore became four played holes altogether: two going out and two coming back.

The shared ground remains a feature of the Old Course. Its layout includes seven double greens and four single greens. In his 1910 book The Golf Courses of the British Isles, Bernard Darwin described outward and inward players passing close together because so many greens were double. He also described golfers calling warnings to one another. A double green accommodates the holes for two different parts of the round, so seven such greens account for fourteen holes; the four single greens complete the total. Counting putting surfaces and counting holes played are different exercises here.

Other clubs followed their own arrangements. Old Tom Morris designed and built Prestwick's original 12-hole course, which measured 3,799 yards. The first Open Championship took place there on October 17, 1860, with eight professionals competing. They played three circuits in one day, making 36 holes altogether. That was 96 years after the St Andrews decision, yet the championship venue still had twelve holes. A competition's total could therefore differ from the number of holes on the course that hosted it.

Prestwick staged every Open through 1870. It expanded to 18 holes in 1882 after acquiring more land to the north of its original layout. The club's history offers a concrete example of the gradual adoption of the St Andrews model: a venue could host the game's leading championship for years before extending its own course to the familiar length.

The wider transition also took time. An R&A historical study reports that more than 75% of new courses during the expansion of golf in the 1880s and 1890s had nine holes. It connects the move toward standard layouts of nine or 18 holes with the Royal and Ancient's growing authority over the rules in the 1890s. A figure cited in the study puts courses with eighteen holes at 51.4% of the total in Great Britain and Ireland in 1923. A recognized model and a majority of actual courses were different milestones.

Starting places changed as well. The same study explains that early rules placed the tee within a specified distance of the hole just completed. Different codes allowed distances ranging from one to twelve club lengths. This was a system in which the previous hole helped determine where the next began. The history of tees is another reminder that the organization of a round developed alongside changes to the grounds themselves.

The standard also leaves room for shorter play. In its explanation of the 2019 rules, the R&A and USGA described a round as eighteen or fewer holes, in the order set by the committee. They explicitly recognized nine-hole rounds as well as the traditional longer format. Their explanation addresses golfers' time constraints and encourages shorter rounds. The result is a distinction between the customary full round of 18 holes and the range of rounds the rules permit. St Andrews supplied the influential pattern; golf's history contains plenty of other counts.

True or False?

Golf has been played over 18 holes since the earliest days of the game at St Andrews.

Show the answer

The Record

False. The Old Course at St Andrews had 22 holes until October 4, 1764, when the Society of St Andrews Golfers reduced it to 18, the number that later became standard.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me the real story” you agree to Sport Debunk’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.