The William Webb Ellis story and its single source
The published account behind rugby's best-known origin story came from a man who was not there. The tale that William Webb Ellis caught the ball and ran with it during a school match at Rugby School in 1823 comes from Matthew Bloxam, who first wrote about it in 1876, more than half a century later and four years after Ellis had died. Bloxam said he had heard it from an unnamed source. The story still names rugby's World Cup trophy, but its evidence is thinner than its fame.
William Webb Ellis himself is well documented. Wikipedia's biography records that he was born in Salford, Lancashire, in 1806, the son of a cavalry officer killed in the Peninsular War in 1812. His mother moved to Rugby so that her sons could attend Rugby School at no cost as local foundationers. He was at the school from 1816 to 1825, where he was described as a good scholar and cricketer. A school contemporary, the Rev. Thomas Harris, later told the Old Rugbeian inquiry that he was "generally regarded as inclined to take unfair advantages at football."
His later career was in the Church. Oxford's alumni register records his matriculation at Brasenose College on 23 March 1825, his bachelor's degree in 1829 and his master's degree in 1831. He also played cricket, including for Oxford against Cambridge in 1827. He served as chaplain of St George's Chapel, Albemarle Street, and rector of St Clement Danes in the Strand, and in 1855 became rector of Magdalen Laver in Essex. He never married, and he died in the south of France in 1872. His grave at Menton was rediscovered in 1958.
The story surfaced through a newspaper question. In 1876, Wikipedia records, Arthur George Guillemard, a former Rugby pupil and one of the founders of the Rugby Union, wrote to The Standard asking where rugby football had come from. Bloxam, an antiquarian and another former pupil, replied that the handling game had not been known in his own time at the school. Then, in October 1876, he wrote to The Meteor, the school magazine, that he had since learnt the change allowing the ball to be carried "originated with a town boy or foundationer of the name of Ellis, Webb Ellis." Wikipedia's Bloxam biography identifies him as the sole source of the story.
Bloxam was not a witness. The Dictionary of National Biography records his entry to Rugby School in 1813 and his legal apprenticeship in 1821, before the match he described. In another letter to The Meteor in December 1880 he expanded his account: under the rules he described, a boy who caught the ball was supposed to retire backwards before kicking, but Ellis, "for the first time, disregarded this rule," and rushed forwards with the ball in his hands. Bloxam admitted he did not know the result of the game or how the infringement became a standing rule.
His account also shows what the legend often leaves out. In Bloxam's description, catching and handling the ball were already allowed at Rugby; the forbidden action was running forward with it. His 1880 account says William Webb Ellis caught the ball, rather than picking it up from the ground.
The school's old boys tried to settle the question. In 1895, after a published account of the game's origins in the Badminton Library, the Old Rugbeian Society appointed a sub-committee that wrote to former pupils from the 1820s and 1830s. Its 1897 report credited Ellis with the innovation "in all probability." A plaque placed on the Close in 1900 credits Ellis with "a fine disregard for the rules." But the evidence the inquiry gathered was mixed. Thomas Hughes, author of Tom Brown's Schooldays, told the inquiry that running in with the ball was not absolutely forbidden in 1834 but was frowned on, that it grew popular in 1838 and 1839 through a powerful runner named Jem Mackie, and that he made running lawful with restrictions as captain of Big-Side. Hughes also said the Webb Ellis tradition had not survived into his own time.
Historians have questioned the report's motives. Wikipedia cites the sociologists Dunning and Sheard, who argue that the timing of the 1895 investigation, amid the split between rugby union and rugby league, was no coincidence, and that endorsing a simple origin story helped the school assert its authority over a sport slipping from its control. That is an interpretation of the inquiry's purpose, rather than testimony about the supposed run.
The game's governing body keeps the name and acknowledges the legend. William Webb Ellis entered what is now the World Rugby Hall of Fame in 2006, and since 1987 the men's Rugby World Cup winners have received the trophy named for him. World Rugby's Playing Charter describes the story as a legend. Rugby School's own football laws were first put in writing in 1845. Earlier written football rules survive for Edinburgh's Foot-Ball Club from 1833, including a ban on tripping. Those rules illustrate why the 1845 date needs its school context. The earliest known written account of the 1823 run came from a man who was not there.
- Wikipedia, William Webb Ellis — en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, Matthew Bloxam — en.wikipedia.org
- Joseph Foster, Alumni Oxonienses, volume 2, page 422 — en.wikisource.org
- Tony Collins, A Social History of English Rugby Union, prologue and page 3 — api.pageplace.de
- Dictionary of National Biography, Matthew Holbeche Bloxam (1901) — en.wikisource.org
- Wikipedia, Rugby School — en.wikipedia.org
- World Rugby Passport, Playing Charter — passport.world.rugby
- Wikipedia, Webb Ellis Cup — en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, World Rugby Hall of Fame — en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, Foot-Ball Club — en.wikipedia.org
- Rules of The Foot-Ball Club (1833), original text — en.wikisource.org